Image of shocked teen looking at phone

Photo Illustration by Sean McCabe; Shutterstock.com (Teen); via TikTok (Social Media)

STANDARDS

Common Core: RH.6-8.1, RH.6-8.2, RH.6-8.4, RH.6-8.6, RH.6-8.7, RH.6-8.8, WHST.6-8.4, RI.6-8.1, RI.6-8.2, RI.6-8.4, RI.6-8.6, RI.6-8.7, RI.6-8.8, W.6-8.4, SL.6-8.1

NCSS: Culture • Time, Continuity, and Change • Individuals, Groups, and Institutions • Production, Distribution, and Consumption • Science, Technology, and Society

MEDIA LITERACY

Should You Trust Your Feed?

More than half of teens get their news from social media. But are your favorite accounts giving you the full story? Here’s how to find out.

Dylan Page calls himself the “News Daddy.” He recaps current events in clips with titles like “WW3 in 2024?!” His TikTok account has 10.5 million followers—that’s more than The New York Times, CNN, and The Washington Post combined.

As Page’s success shows, the way we get information is changing. Your parents’ generation turned to TV and newspapers. But more than half of teens ages 14 to 19 today get their news mainly from social media, according to a 2022 survey by the consulting firm Deloitte. 

Keeping up with news on social media is convenient and fast. But in one study, fact-checking experts found that 20 percent of TikTok’s suggested videos about major news events contained misinformation—incorrect or misleading information. (False information that is deliberately spread to confuse or deceive people is called disinformation.) 

That’s why you need to think critically about what you encounter online. Are you already a pro at telling fact from fiction? Answer the questions below to find out.

Q: Maybe it’s just FOMO (fear of missing out), but you should definitely watch a video titled “Urgent warning!,” right? 

NO. Exaggerated claims and titles are often signs of disinformation. They are used because you’re less likely to question whether a claim is true when your emotions are triggered. Lisa Manganello, a school librarian who teaches media literacy at South Brunswick High School in New Jersey, suggests analyzing the language of a post before you engage with it. Does the story imply that you might be in danger if you don’t click (“Huge risk!,” “This is crazy!,” “Beware!”)? Do any words in the title seem to be steering you to support one viewpoint or feel a certain way? Most trustworthy news outlets focus on facts, not feelings, in their headlines. 

Shutterstock.com

Q: An influencer claims to know the latest news about your favorite game. Her graphics look professional. Should you dig deeper before trusting her content? 

YES. Online tools make it easy for anyone to quickly create a well-designed and professional-looking account. Compelling photos, catchy music, and even talking cartoons can distract you from fuzzy facts, says Angie Drobnic Holan, director of the International Fact-Checking Network. Look beyond the flash and focus on whether a source provides evidence for its claims. For example, a post about the health effects of energy drinks should include major studies and quotes from doctors or other medical experts.

Q: Yikes! You just read a post claiming that your favorite cup contains lead, a poisonous metal. Should you toss it?  

Shutterstock.com

NO. (Or at least not until you do a little more research.) Misleading posts often do contain a kernel of truth. However, they often leave out key information needed to put that truth into perspective. For instance, you may have seen a story on social media recently that popular Stanley tumblers are made with lead, which can make people sick. But the full story is more complicated: The cups’ bases do contain a sealing material that has lead in it—but it’s covered by stainless steel and doesn’t come into contact with areas we touch or drink from. Make sure you get all the information on viral news topics by scanning fact-checking sites like Snopes.com or PolitiFact.com. There are also resources created specifically for teens (see “Unsure About a Post?,” below)

Unsure About a Post?

These teen-focused resources help identify misinformation.

MediaWise
@Mediawise 
on TikTok and Instagram 
This group’s posts feature real teens fact-checking trending topics. Two worth checking out: “Did the Eiffel Tower catch on fire?” and “Breathing causes climate change?”

News Literacy Project 
@newslitproject 
on Instagram and TikTok
This nonprofit breaks down viral videos, looks at the facts, and points out problems, like altered images and fake audio.

Above the Noise
(on YouTube)

This PBS series gives tips on how to cut through the hype and be informed consumers of the news. 

Q: You keep seeing posts about a new jelly bean-flavored pizza. It seems fishy, but a search for “jelly bean pizza” pulls up more headlines. Does that mean it’s real? 

Shutterstock.com

NO. Just because a story appears on multiple accounts or websites doesn’t mean it’s legit. The rise of AI-generated content has made it easy to reproduce false information quickly. And when you search for a term taken directly from questionable content, you’re likely to pull up even more of the same info. Instead, do a general search about the topic (“new types of pizza”). The results should show a URL for each suggested link, and sometimes a date. Look for recognizable URLs, such as those of major newspapers. Keep in mind that just because something ranks high in search results doesn’t mean it’s true. 

Q: A breaking news video about aliens that look like trees sounds false, for sure. But it also could be funny. Could any harm come from watching it? 

Shutterstock.com

YES. Every time you engage with content online, it affects the platform’s algorithm. That is a set of rules that apps and websites use to determine what content to show each user. An algorithm is more likely to show you news about subjects related to topics you regularly click on and viewpoints you agree with so you will spend more time watching. That creates a filter bubble, which can make you miss important news you haven’t expressed an interest in or give you just one perspective on a topic. So train the algorithm. If a post seems outrageous, resist clicking. Make sure your “follow” list includes topics you want to know about. And seek out multiple sources and viewpoints to balance your media diet.

YOUR TURN

Make a Plan

Highlight two tips that feel most important to you. How can they help you tell fact from fiction? How might using them affect your scrolling? 


videos (1)
Skills Sheets (6)
Skills Sheets (6)
Skills Sheets (6)
Skills Sheets (6)
Skills Sheets (6)
Skills Sheets (6)
Lesson Plan (2)
Lesson Plan (2)
Text-to-Speech