Prisoners in a ghetto in Lwów, Poland, during World War II

Photo courtesy of Ghetto Fighters’ House Museum, Israel/Photo Archive

STANDARDS

NCSS: Culture • Time, Continuity, and Change • Individual Development and Identity • Individuals, Groups, and Institutions • Power, Authority, and Governance • Global Connections

Common Core: RH.6-8.1, RH.6-8.2, RH.6-8.3, RH.6-8.4, RH.6-8.5, RH.6-8.6, RH.6-8.7, RH.6-8.9, WHST.6-8.2, WHST.6-8.4, WHST.6-8.9, RI.6-8.1, RI.6-8.2, RI.6-8.3, RI.6-8.4, RI.6-8.5, RI.6-8.6, RI.6-8.7, RI.6-8.9, W.6-8.2, W.6-8.4, W.6-8.9

WORLD HISTORY

True Teens of History

Surviving the Holocaust

As a teen, Janine Binder Oberrotman lost her homeand her parentsto the NazisHere’s how she persevered

Question: How does Janine Binder Oberrotman’s story help you understand the Holocaust?

IMEC/Courtesy of Janine Oberrotman/The Washington Post

Janine Binder at age 20, after World War II

Janine Binder had seconds to make her decisionone that could change her entire life.

It was March 1943. World War II (1939-1945) was raging across Europe. The 17-year-old and her mother were imprisoned in a ghetto in Lwów (luh-VOOF), Poland.* Along with tens of thousands of other Jewish people, they had been forced to live in a fenced-in section of the city. They had no rights and little food, and they faced constant threats of violence.

*Today the city is Lviv, Ukraine.

But somehow on that day, a gate in the barbed wire fence was open, and there were no guards in sight.

Janine’s mother pushed her toward the opening. “You go right now!” she whispered. She shoved a knapsack containing false identification papers into her daughter’s hands.

If Janine were caught, she could be killed. But there was also a chance she could escape.

The teen hesitated. She and her mother were barely surviving. But outside the fence was just as dangerous. German dictator Adolf Hitler and his Nazi forces were carrying out their plan to conquer Europe and kill all its Jewish people.

If Janine were caught, she could be killed. But there was also a chance she could escape and start a new life.

With tears gushing from her eyes, Janine embraced her mother one last time. Then she moved through the open gate, not daring to look back.

I didn’t know where I was going,” Janine later said. “But I knew that another part of my life was starting.”

Janine was no longer just a teen. She was now a teen on the run.

Hitler’s Rise

Roger Viollet via Getty Images

German dictator Adolf Hitler

Before Hitler’s rule began, Janine lived a happy life in Lwów. An only child, she was born on October 1, 1925. Her father, Maurice, owned a business. Her mother, Maria, stayed at home to take care of her. The family ate meals together and took vacations each year.

But life started changing in 1933the year Hitler rose to power in neighboring Germany. Hitler and his Nazi Party gained support by tapping into existing prejudice against the country’s Jewish residents. The Nazis falsely blamed them for Germany’s financial troubles and its defeat in World War I (1914-1918).

Such prejudice against Jewish people—known as antisemitism—had existed for centuries in Europe. But once in control of Germany, Hitler focused the full power of his government on erasing them. The Nazis stripped Jewish people in Germany of their citizenship and the right to vote. They also banned them from holding certain jobs, and many Jewish businesses were seized.

But the Nazis didn’t stop there. On September 1, 1939—exactly one month before Janine turned 14—Hitler’s army invaded western Poland. The invasion sparked World War II. Within the next few years, the Nazis conquered much of Europe. Eventually, nations including the United Kingdom and the United States formed the Allied powers to stop the Nazis and countries fighting alongside them (see "Europe in 1942" map, below).

As the Nazis’ empire grew, antisemitism increased. Many people turned against their Jewish neighbors. They attacked them in the streets and destroyed their businesses.

Nazi forces began ordering millions of Jewish people across Europe into concentration campsprisons or places of forced labor, some of which were designed to systematically murder them. Those who weren’t killed were forced to work long hours with little food.

The Nazis also built more than 1,000 ghettos and forced Jewish people into them. The ghettos were a way to persecute and isolate Jewish people before they were sent to concentration camps, explains Helene Sinnreich. She is a religious studies professor and Holocaust expert at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville.

An Introduction to the Holocaust
Watch a video about the causes, impacts, and aftermath of the Holocaust.

Robbed of Their Rights

As antisemitism continued to spread, Janine’s father was forced to give up his business and take a lower-paying job. The family often didn’t have enough to eat. But their city in eastern Poland was still free from Nazi control. At 15, Janine continued to have moments of normalcy. She enjoyed sleeping in, reading, and spending time with her friends.

Then, in June 1941, Nazi forces invaded Lwów. They murdered thousands of Jewish residents within weeks. Those who were spared were robbed of their rights. They could not attend schools or use public transportation. And like elsewhere in Nazi-controlled Europe, Jewish people in Lwów had to start wearing armbands with the Star of David, a Jewish symbol (see sidebar, below).

For the next few months, Janine and her parents stayed mostly in their apartment other than when her father went to work. But Nazi officials were creating a ghetto in Lwów. By the end of 1941, they began forcibly relocating Jewish people there

United States Holocaust Memorial Museum

Artifact: Under Nazi rule, Jewish people were required to wear armbands like this one at all times. The bands were stitched with the Star of David, a Jewish symbol. The Nazi requirement was a way to isolate and humiliate Jewish people. “When someone was wearing a star,” says professor Helene Sinnreich, “it was an indicator that they did not belong.” 

Forced Into a Ghetto

Janine and her parents were able to avoid the ghetto at first. For several months, they hid at friends’ homes. But by the summer of 1942, they had run out of places to hide. Their first night in the ghetto, they slept outside in a crowded courtyard.

The family eventually found a cramped apartment to live in, but Janine and her parents were never settled. Conditions in the ghetto were miserable. Many people froze to death during winter because there was no heat.

Hunger was extreme because the Nazis severely restricted food portions. They allowed Jewish people only tiny amounts of bread or potatoes to last entire families several days. Some prisoners had to beg or steal to eat, and many of them died of starvation and disease.

People who survived the horrible conditions faced the terror of roundupswhen they were apprehended without warning and sent to concentration camps.

Imagno/Getty Images

Jewish people in Warsaw, Poland, are forced onto a train by Nazi soldiers.

Janine’s family moved from place to place to avoid being seized. During the roundups, they hid in attics and closets.

With every roundup, Nazi forces were slowly destroying the ghetto and everyone inside it. “Under the Nazi regime, Jews didn’t have the right to live,” Sinnreich says. “Hitler’s goal was for them to die.”

Most ghetto prisoners who were captured were shot dead or were sent to concentration camps to be killed in poison gas chambers. This was part of a plan called the Final Solutionthe Nazis’ intent to systematically murder all of Europe’s 9.5 million Jewish people. It was the devastating last stage of what came to be known as the Holocaust.

We still had hope because as long as you live, until the end, you hope.”

A Daring Escape

In early 1943, Janine’s father was rounded up while he was out getting potatoes for his family. Nazi soldiers sent him to a concentration camp, where he was killed. “I was absolutely heartbroken,” she recalled.

Not long after learning of her father’s death, the teen and her mother found the open gate in the ghetto. They had been out walking. As Janine later recalled, they were grieving and discussing their future.

We still had hope,” Janine said, “because as long as you live, until the end, you hope.”

When they discovered the opening, everything happened in a flash. One minute, Janine was a ghetto prisoner. The next, she was on the outside, already aching for her mother. The teen hoped that she could somehow return for her. But in that moment, Janine realized she needed to blend in. She dried her eyes and ripped off her armband.

Horace Abrahams/Hulton Archive/Getty Images

Concentration camp prisoners in Germany cheer as they are freed by the U.S. Army in 1945.

 “I Thought I Wouldn’t Last

The small bag Janine’s mother had handed her right before her escape held her ticket to freedom: false identification papers given to Janine by a friend before she was forced into the ghetto. The papers identified her as a Catholic person, which gave her a better chance of not being rounded up. The teen set out to find her aunt, who was living in secret as a Catholic in Lwów.

Her aunt helped her get to the Polish village of Ponikwa, where her grandmother and uncle were living as Catholics. Janine thought she would be safer there. But any moment of peace the teen may have felt in getting away from Lwów was short-lived.

Soon after Janine arrived in Ponikwa, she was arrested by Nazi police on suspicion of being Jewish. The officers couldn’t prove her background, though, so they didn’t send her to a concentration camp. Instead, they sent her to Stuttgart, Germany, for forced labor.

For the next two years, Janine had to work nearly nonstop with no pay in a restaurant kitchen. She faced grueling, 15-hour shifts washing dishes. Once, she was so badly burned by a pot of steaming hot water that she had to be hospitalized.

I was so overworked that I thought I wouldn’t last,” she said.

Still, Janine felt lucky. Many forced laborers worked in more dangerous jobs. They toiled in coal mines and chemical plantsoften under the watch of Nazi guards. They were fed very little, and the majority of workers slept in crowded barracks.

Janine had her own room above the restaurant where she could sleep, and she never went hungry. She was still working at that restaurant in May 1945, when Germany surrendered to the Allied powers.

The war in Europe was finally over, but the human loss was catastrophic. In total, the Nazis had killed 6 million of Europe’s Jewish residentstwo-thirds of the continent’s Jewish population. They also killed millions of other people.

Tragically, Janine’s mother was one of the millions who lost her life. She was killed in the Lwów ghetto in 1943, the same year that Janine had escaped.

Courtney Sturgeon/The Washington Post

Janine Binder Oberrotman and Dhilan Stanley

My Friend, Janine

Dhilan Stanley has heard Janine Binder Oberrotman’s story of survival. The 14-year-old volunteers with her regularly at the Illinois Holocaust Museum and Education Center.

The pair (above) works on the museum’s welcome desk. In quieter moments, Dhilan enjoys talking with Janine about his schoolwork and his cats. But when visitors drop by, Janine is eager to describe her experiences to them.

I can see people’s understanding of the Holocaust growing as they listen to her,” Dhilan says.

The ninth-grader wants to do his part to make sure the Holocaust is never forgotten. He recently started a project called Gen Z for Humanity. His goal is to raise awareness among kids about the Holocaust using social media and other efforts.

Dhilan says Janine inspires him to act. “She has taught me to live life to the fullest.”

—with reporting by Anna Starecheski

Telling Her Story 

Shortly after the war, Janine met her future husband, Joseph Oberrotman, a fellow Holocaust survivor. They married and started a family. In 1953, they moved with their young son to Chicago, Illinois. They soon had two more sons. Janine Oberrotman went on to become a middle school teacher and later a career counselor.

Today Janine is 99 years old and still lives in Illinois. But the warand the beloved parents she lostare never far from her mind. She has asked herself many times over the years why she survived the Holocaust when so many did not. She believes it’s so she can share her story.

Tens of thousands of people have heard Janine speak at various events and in interviews. She is also a volunteer at the Illinois Holocaust Museum and Education Center in Skokie, Illinois. Through her words, the horrors of the war are not forgotten.

Janine has said that her goal is to ensure that an atrocity like the Holocaust never happens again.

There’s one thing I could never stand and still cannot stand,” she says, “and that is injustice.”


A full accounting of Janine Binder Oberrotman’s experience can be found at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. She and her family approved this version for Junior Scholastic.

YOUR TURN

Analyze a Photo

Choose one of these photographs to study: the Lwów ghetto, the train, or the concentration camp. How would you describe the mood? How does the photo help you understand the Holocaust?

Leveled Articles (1)
PDF
Leveled Text: Surviving the Holocaust

A lower-Lexile® version of the article in a printer-friendly PDF

Text-to-Speech