STANDARDS

Common Core: RH.6-8.1, RH.6-8.2, RH.6-8.4, RH.6-8.6, RH.6-8.7, RH.6-8.8, WHST.6-8.4, RI.6-8.1, RI.6-8.2, RI.6-8.4, RI.6-8.6, RI.6-8.7, W.6-8.4, SL.6-8.1

NCSS: Culture • Individuals, Groups, and Institutions • Production, Distribution, and Consumption • Science, Technology, and Society

MEDIA LITERACY

Can You Spot the Fakes?

Misleading videos are on the rise online. Here’s how to keep from being fooled.

via tiktok

Only one of these three videos is true. Can you guess which one?

1. Fake: Dumpy the frog was digitally enlarged. 2. True: Major news sources reported that the bear got in while the homeowners were out. 3. Fake: The 225-ton statue is firmly bolted in place.

As You Read, Think About: What clues can help you spot phony videos? 

A giant frog sits motionless on a table. Then suddenly, without warning, it pounces. The frog pulls half a banana into its enormous mouth. In the blink of an eye, everything but the peel is gone. 

Dumpy, that hungry amphibian, racked up millions of views on TikTok last fall—but not because of its appetite. People were wowed by its size. Australian tree frogs are usually only 4 to 5 inches long, and this one looked as big as a football!

After the frog went viral, its Minnesota-based owner came clean. He admitted to editing the video to make his pet look like a giant—all for social media views. 

Dumpy’s altered footage was harmless fun. But it is an example of a growing problem: Misleading videos are on the rise—and they’re becoming increasingly hard to spot. 

On TikTok, about 20 percent of videos on news topics contain inaccurate information, according to NewsGuard. That group tracks the trustworthiness of online content. And while some manipulated videos are created for entertainment, others have a darker intent: to deliberately mislead people and spread false information.  

That’s a big problem because watching videos can fool our brains into feeling like we witnessed the content firsthand. And that feeling makes us more likely to trust videos, says Anya Williams, 17. She is a teen fact-checker for MediaWise, a group that teaches people how to spot false information online. 

“We have a tendency to believe in what we’re watching because we’re seeing it with our own eyes,” Anya explains. As a result, she says, videos can “influence our thoughts and our decisions.”

A giant frog sits on a table. It is very still. Suddenly, without warning, it pounces. The frog pulls half a banana into its huge mouth. In the blink of an eye, everything but the peel is gone.

That hungry amphibian is named Dumpy. It racked up millions of views on TikTok last fall. But not because of its appetite. People were wowed by its size. Australian tree frogs are usually only 4 to 5 inches long. This one looked as big as a football!

The frog went viral. Then its Minnesota-based owner came clean. He admitted he had edited the video to make his pet look like a giant. He did it to get social media views.

Dumpy’s altered footage was harmless fun. But it is an example of a growing problem: Misleading videos are on the rise. And they are becoming increasingly hard to spot.

On TikTok, about 20 percent of videos on news topics contain inaccurate information. That is according to NewsGuard, a group that tracks the trustworthiness of online content. Some manipulated videos are created for entertainment. But others have a darker intent: to mislead people on purpose and spread false information.

That is a big problem. The reason: Watching videos can fool our brains into feeling like we witnessed the content firsthand. And that feeling makes us more likely to trust videos, says Anya Williams, 17. She is a teen fact-checker for MediaWise. That group teaches people how to spot false information online.

“We have a tendency to believe in what we’re watching because we’re seeing it with our own eyes,” Anya explains. As a result, she says, videos can “influence our thoughts and our decisions.”

False Footage

via Twitter

In this deepfake of Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, his head shifted awkwardly and his arms stayed glued to his sides.

People started manipulating photos in the mid-1800s, shortly after photographs were first invented. Some cut and glued multiple images together by hand. The introduction of digital cameras in the 1990s made altering photos easier and more common. And the rise of social media in the early 2000s gave people new ways to quickly and widely share misleading images. 

Today just about anyone can manipulate and post videos too. All you need is a device, such as a phone, and basic editing software. Then you can rearrange, add, cut, or change footage from real videos. 

For example, you might have seen a video of basketball star LeBron James traveling (taking several steps without dribbling) during a game this past spring. But that clip was altered. For a reason that is unclear, someone had edited the footage to make it look like James had broken one of basketball’s biggest rules, when in reality he hadn’t.

Some people go even further, using artificial intelligence to digitally manipulate voices and faces. They make it look like someone said or did something they didn’t. These types of fabricated videos are called deepfakes—and they are among the hardest to detect.

Such videos can be dangerous. In one instance, someone created a deepfake to influence the war between Russia and Ukraine. Those two nations have been battling since Russia invaded Ukraine in February 2022. Shortly after the war started, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky appeared in a video calling for his troops to surrender. But the footage was a deepfake. The creator had pieced together Zelensky’s head with a body from separate footage. 

The video was quickly called out as false, but experts say it could have had significant consequences on the war if it hadn’t been questioned. The deepfake also made it harder for some people to trust the real Zelensky videos that followed. They were worried that those videos might have been manipulated too.

People started manipulating photos in the mid-1800s. That was shortly after photographs were first invented. Some people cut and glued multiple images together by hand. Then digital cameras were introduced in the 1990s. They made altering photos easier and more common. Then came social media in the early 2000s. That gave people new ways to quickly and widely share misleading images.

Today just about anyone can manipulate and post videos too. All you need is a device, such as a phone, and basic editing software. Then you can rearrange, add, cut, or change footage from real videos.

For example, you might have seen a video of basketball star LeBron James traveling (taking several steps without dribbling) during a game this past spring. But that clip was altered. For unknown reasons, someone had edited the footage to make it look like James had broken one of basketball’s biggest rules. In reality, he had not.

Some people go even further. They use artificial intelligence to digitally manipulate voices and faces. They make it look like someone said or did something they did not. These types of fabricated videos are called deepfakes. They are among the hardest to detect.

Such videos can be dangerous. For example, someone created a deepfake to influence the war between Russia and Ukraine. Those two nations have been fighting since Russia invaded Ukraine in February 2022. Shortly after the war started, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky appeared in a video calling for his troops to surrender. But the footage was a deepfake. The creator had pieced together Zelensky’s head with a body from separate footage.

The video was quickly called out as false. But experts say it could have had a major effect on the war if it had not been questioned. The deepfake also made it harder for some people to trust the real Zelensky videos that followed. People were worried that those videos might have been manipulated too.

What You Can Do

One of the best ways to fight back against fake videos is not to share them. But figuring out which ones are altered can be hard, especially because so many videos are uploaded every second. 

Google and other tech companies are developing tools to detect altered videos. Fact-checkers like Anya are also working to call out false content. 

You can be part of the solution too, experts say. Don’t repost every video you see. Instead, think critically about a video’s content first.

Pay attention to details, such as inconsistencies in lighting and shadows, which can indicate that a clip has been edited. Unusual facial or body movements are also red flags, says Anya. 

Listen for speech that seems too fast or too slow, an unnatural-sounding voice, or audio that doesn’t line up with the speaker’s mouth.  

Be wary if a video makes you feel angry or scared, says Erin Olson, a media expert with the News Literacy Project. Creators try to spark strong feelings because an emotional response increases the likelihood that a viewer will share a video without thinking. And the more people who share a video, the more people who can be influenced by it.

Finally, think about how the video affected you—and might influence other people. If you have any doubts about its accuracy, don’t pass it on.

One of the best ways to fight back against fake videos is not to share them. But figuring out which ones are altered can be hard. It is especially tough because so many videos are uploaded every second.

Google and other tech companies are developing tools to detect altered videos. Fact-checkers like Anya are also working to call out false content.

You can be part of the solution too, experts say. Do not repost every video you see. Instead, start by thinking critically about a video’s content.

Pay attention to details, such as inconsistencies in lighting and shadows. They can indicate that a clip has been edited. Unusual facial or body movements are also red flags, says Anya.

Listen for speech that seems too fast or too slow. Check for an unnatural-sounding voice, or audio that does not line up with the speaker’s mouth.

Be cautious if a video makes you feel angry or scared, says Erin Olson. She is a media expert with the News Literacy Project. Creators try to spark strong feelings. That is because an emotional response makes it more likely that a viewer will share a video without thinking. And the more people who share a video, the greater the number who can be influenced by it.

Finally, think about how the video affected you. And consider how it might influence other people. Have any doubts about its accuracy? Then do not pass it on.

Check the Facts

How can you tell if the information in a video is legit? Teen fact-checker Anya Williams is a pro at sorting fact from fiction. Here are her tips.

Courtesy Anya Williams

Anya Williams

CHECK MULTIPLE SOURCES. 
Open several tabs on your browser to compare what credible news sources say about the video’s topic—and what evidence they provide. You can also check claims with trustworthy sites. URLs that end in .gov (run by the U.S. government) or .edu (run by academic institutions) are generally good options. 

DO A REVERSE IMAGE SEARCH. 
Upload a screenshot from the video to an online tool like Google Images. This can help you see where else the video appears. Comparing the video with other versions can help you determine if it came from a reputable source and see whether it has been manipulated or taken out of context.   

TRUST YOUR GUT.
Is the video sensational? Or does it have awkward gaps or odd transitions? If so, be cautious about believing what it says.  

CHECK MULTIPLE SOURCES. 
Open several tabs on your browser to compare what credible news sources say about the video’s topic—and what evidence they provide. You can also check claims with trustworthy sites. URLs that end in .gov (run by the U.S. government) or .edu (run by academic institutions) are generally good options. 

DO A REVERSE IMAGE SEARCH. 
Upload a screenshot from the video to an online tool like Google Images. This can help you see where else the video appears. Comparing the video with other versions can help you determine if it came from a reputable source and see whether it has been manipulated or taken out of context.   

TRUST YOUR GUT.
Is the video sensational? Or does it have awkward gaps or odd transitions? If so, be cautious about believing what it says.  

Can You Spot Misleading Videos? 

Take our challenge to find out!

Study each video screenshot. Look closely at the image, text, and source. Then decide whether the video’s content is fake or real.

Study each video screenshot. Look closely at the image, text, and source. Then decide whether the video’s content is fake or real.

1

Is this video fake?

1

Is this video fake?

via TikTok

Caption: Adorable seal hitches a ride on surfers' boards



One way to tell: The source, The Independent, has a blue check mark, which many social media companies use to show that the account’s identity has been verified. In addition, other major news outlets also reported about this harbor seal hitching rides off the coast of San Diego, California, during the summer of 2023. 

One way to tell: The source, The Independent, has a blue check mark, which many social media companies use to show that the account’s identity has been verified. In addition, other major news outlets also reported about this harbor seal hitching rides off the coast of San Diego, California, during the summer of 2023. 

2

Is this video fake?

2

Is this video fake?

via TikTok

Caption: This is where you're egg shortage went



One way to tell: The misspelling—you’re instead of your—is a red flag. Although egg prices did rise in early 2023, a national newspaper reported that this footage is of a poultry company in Argentina destroying contaminated eggs later in the year. 

One way to tell: The misspelling—you’re instead of your—is a red flag. Although egg prices did rise in early 2023, a national newspaper reported that this footage is of a poultry company in Argentina destroying contaminated eggs later in the year. 

3

Is this video fake?

3

Is this video fake?

via TikTok

Caption: THIS IS THE WORLD'S LARGEST PIZZA



One way to tell: That blue “verified” check mark indicates that the account holder is trustworthy. The 13,957-square-foot pizza, cooked up at the Los Angeles Convention Center in California in early 2023, broke a Guinness World Record.

One way to tell: That blue “verified” check mark indicates that the account holder is trustworthy. The 13,957-square-foot pizza, cooked up at the Los Angeles Convention Center in California in early 2023, broke a Guinness World Record.

4

Is this video fake?

4

Is this video fake?

via TikTok

Caption: This cat learned to read using Junior Scholastic



One way to tell: Some claims are just too outrageous to believe. While we love this kitty’s taste in magazines, cats can’t read!  

One way to tell: Some claims are just too outrageous to believe. While we love this kitty’s taste in magazines, cats can’t read!  

Interactive Quiz for this article

Click the Google Classroom button below to share the Know the News quiz with your class.

Download .PDF
videos (1)
Skills Sheets (5)
Skills Sheets (5)
Skills Sheets (5)
Skills Sheets (5)
Skills Sheets (5)
Lesson Plan (1)
Leveled Articles (1)
Text-to-Speech