Many members of Congress have criticized President Trump’s emergency declaration.

Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images (Trump, Harris); Charlie Riedel/AP Images (Border Wall); Zach Gibson/Getty Images (Schumer); Drew Angerer/Getty Images (Collins); John Lamparski/Getty Images (Paul); Alex Wroblewski/Bloomberg via Getty Images (Pelosi); David Paul Morris/Bloomberg via Getty Images (Hurd); Nik Merkulov/Shutterstock.com (Background)

STANDARDS

Common Core: RH.6-8.2, RH.6-8.4, RH.6-8.7, RI.6-8.2, RI.6-8.10, SL.6-8.1

C3 (D2/6-8): Civ.3, Civ.4, Civ.5, Civ.8, Civ.10, Civ.12, His.1, His.14

NCSS: Power, authority, and governance; Global connections

IN THE NEWS

U.S. Government

Border Wall Battle

The president has declared a national emergency to help construct a wall along the U.S.-Mexico border. Many in Congress are opposed. Could the move end up shifting the government’s delicate balance of power?

You might not hear sirens or see flashing lights, but the United States is on alert. In February, President Donald Trump declared a national emergency to help pay for the construction of a wall along the U.S.-Mexico border

Trump says building a wall is the best way to put an end to the flow of undocumented immigrants and illegal drugs crossing into the United States. About 650 miles of barriers already stand along the border (see map, below). Trump has vowed to block off 1,000 miles more

But there’s a catch: Many experts disagree that there is a threat at the border. That’s why when Trump asked for $5.7 billion to build the wall last year, Congress refused.

The clash led to a government shutdown in December that lasted a record 35 days. In February, hoping to avoid another shutdown, Congress approved $1.38 billion for border fencingabout one-quarter of what Trump had asked for.

That is where the national emergency comes in. Declaring one gives a president temporary powers that increase his or her authority. Trump plans to use those special powers to redirect billions of dollars from other parts of the federal government’s budget toward constructing the border wall

The situation has sparked a national debate. Why are many Americans up in arms over the move, and what could it mean for you? Here’s what you need to know.

The Border Wall
A video about the U.S.-Mexico border and barriers the U.S. has built, or planned to build, on it over the years

1. Declaring a national emergency grants the president powers typically outside his control 

Since the late 1800s, Congress has passed more than 120 different statutes that, once a national emergency has been declared, permit presidents to take certain steps normally forbidden by law. Lawmakers wanted to make sure presidents could take immediate action if the U.S. came under threat. Under the National Emergencies Act of 1976, once a president declares a national emergency, he or she can activate any of those emergency statutes. In this case, Trump is drawing on a statute that permits money that was originally set aside for military construction to be used for something else.

2. Not everyone agrees there’s an emergency

Is there a crisis at the U.S. border with Mexico? Trump says yes. “We have an invasion of drugs, invasion of gangs, invasion of people, and it’s unacceptable,” he stated while announcing the emergency declaration. More people were caught trying to cross the border last year than in 2017, Customs and Border Protection reports show

But many experts disagree with Trump and say there is no national emergency at the border. Dozens of former U.S. security officials have criticized the declaration. They point out that the number of people trying to cross the border illegally is the lowest it’s been in decades. And since nearly 90 percent of drugs seized at the border come through legal ports of entry, critics say a wall would have little effect on their flow into the country.

US Air Force photo by Airman First Class Daniel A. Hernandez 

ADDED PROTECTION: Army engineers reinforce existing fencing in Texas with wire last year.

3. Congress controls the federal budget

America’s founders gave Congressnot the presidentthe power to tax and the power to spend public money for the federal government

Why? The founders wanted the American people to have control of government spending. They reasoned that the U.S. House of Representatives most closely reflects the opinions of U.S. citizens. That’s because the number of House representatives each state has is determined by that state’s population. Plus, those representatives are elected by the people every two years

Because Congress sets the federal budget, presidents need lawmakers’ approval to fund certain projectslike a border wall. Facing pressure from constituents who opposed spending $5.7 billion on the wall, as Trump requested, Congress instead gave $1.38 billion for fencing.

Slideshow

4. Some say Trump is misusing emergency powers 

Many lawmakers argue that Trump is abusing his emergency powers in this instance. That’s because he has said he is using them specifically to go against the will of Congress. “I didn’t need to do this. . . . I just want to get it done faster, that’s all,” Trump stated while declaring the national emergency in February

It’s the only time that a president has ever gone to Congress, asked for money, been denied, and then used emergency powers to get that very same thing,” explains Andrew Boyle of the New York University School of Law’s Brennan Center for Justice

5. Congress probably can’t block Trump’s emergency declaration

The Constitution includes checks and balances to ensure that one branch of the federal government can’t dominate another branch

But in this situation, Congress’s hands may essentially be tied. In February, the House passed a resolution to stop the emergency declaration. As this issue went to press, the U.S. Senate was expected to do the same. Trump can veto that resolution, however

Congress could then try to override Trump’s veto. But that would be difficult to do. It would take two-thirds of both the House and the Senate to override a veto by the president. Experts say there are enough Republicans in Congress who support the wall to prevent that from happening.

Barrier Status

Existing fencing and barriers span about one-third of the 1,954-mile border separating the U.S. and Mexico.

Jim McMahon/Mapman®

6. The Supreme Court could get involved

The Supreme Court could end up having the final say about whether Trump can use emergency powers to redirect money toward the wallif a lawsuit makes its way to the nation’s highest court

Indeed, several lawsuits have already been filed in lower courts to stop the declarationincluding one by 16 states. Some plaintiffs argue that there is no emergency. Others say the statute Trump is trying to use does not apply the way he wants to use it. A judge could temporarily halt the use of emergency funds until the full case is heard in court. The legal process could take years, experts say.

The Trump administration also faces lawsuits from landowners who own some of the property on which the wall is expected to be built.

Mario Tama/Getty Images

BARRICADES UP: Workers replace fences with bigger barriers along the border in January. 

7. Wall construction hasn’t started yet

Construction hasn’t begun on new sections yet, but experts say Trump could get the work on fencing or barriers started using the $1.38 billion Congress did approve. That’s enough to cover about 55 miles. Trump would most likely have that construction start on land already owned by the government to avoid further holdups, Boyle says

The president has also increased military presence. About 6,000 members of the U.S. Armed Forces now secure the border, in addition to the Customs and Border Protection agents who were already in place. The troops are expected to remain there until at least the fall.

8. What this means for the futureand you

Some experts warn that the most dangerous part of this emergency isn’t illegal border crossings. Rather, it’s the precedent that Trump’s declaration may set: that a president can use national emergencies to bypass a disapproving Congress

Once that line is crossed, it makes it easier for other people in the future to cross it,” Boyle says. That could shift the careful balance of government power by strengthening the executive branch and weakening the legislative branch, some lawmakers caution.

Other people predict that Trump’s move will convince legislators to overhaul the National Emergencies Act to tighten restrictions on how presidents can use the statutes. That would give more control back to Congress, but could weaken presidents’ ability to respond to threats.

Either way, the situation underscores how important it is for everyoneeven teensto stay engaged and involved, Boyle explains. “Our democracy is fragile,” he says. “It requires engagement and good intentions from people with all sorts of views and experiences.”

Write About It! Should the national emergency stay in effect? Find at least two facts or details from the story to support your opinion, and conduct additional research online. Then write an argument essay explaining your point of view.

Skills Sheets (1)
Leveled Articles (1)
PDF
Leveled Text: Border Wall Battle

A lower-Lexile version of the article in a printer-friendly PDF

Text-to-Speech